SWAN asked our comrades in New Zealand to tell us about the realities of social work down there. The following piece is fascinating, especially as the UK moves towards new social work regulation, increased privatisation of emergency services including children and families social work, and a rise in racism. Thank you so much to our NZ colleagues for this enlightening and thought-provoking piece.

 

Kia ora and comradely greetings from Aotearoa New Zealand!

 

This message is in response to a request by Luis Arevalo to offer a commentary on the state of social work in Aotearoa New Zealand. First of all, good wishes on your 2016 conference. Many social workers in New Zealand follow the work of SWAN with great interest, you are a constant source of inspiration for our own efforts to keep progressive social work alive.

There are many aspects of social work in Aotearoa that would be recognisable to our United Kingdom social work colleagues, and others that are unique to the history of this former British colony. 

Aotearoa has a landmass that is larger than the UK, and a population that is smaller than Scotland. Most of the population is concentrated in a few cities in the North and South Islands with a third living in Auckland City (currently subject to a massive housing bubble, unaffordable rent and house prices, and a rise in homelessness that is reaching crisis proportions).

 New Zealand is well known for its vast, sparsely populated and very beautiful rural hinterland that is home to a thriving tourist trade. Our rural communities are also home to a high-intensity, unsustainable, dairy farming industry (the engine of the New Zealand economy); and to many hollowed out, impoverished and forgotten rural towns and villages.

The contemporary demographics of our population are complex and dynamic. In the last 87 years the population of New Zealand has tripled, and it continues to be a major destination for new migrants with almost a quarter of all residents having been born overseas. Our history is steeped in colonisation and its continuing impact on Māori, the indigenous people of Aotearoa. Māori form 15% of the population but are grossly overrepresented in many negative social indicators: over 50% of the prison population, and over 50% of the child in care population are of Māori descent. Māori  have higher mortality rates, and Māori suicide rates are almost twice as high as non-Maori. 

 Since the 1980s successive neoliberal governments (of the left and right) have deprecated state welfare. Overall rates of child poverty now stand at 29% and we have an infant mortality rate higher than the OECD average. The present neoliberal, National Party government (led by John Key, a former foreign exchange trader) is currently in its third term of office. In previous terms they introduced a privatised Serco run prison, set up charter schools and a national school curriculum, and transformed our welfare state into a workfare state. In their current term of office they have turned their attention to social services and child protection. 

Last year the Productivity Commission published a report called “More Effective Social Services" that is founded on a “social investment approach” attempting to do "more with less", targeting services on specific user groups, and introducing alternative funding models including “social bonds” (enabling low risk private sector investment in social services). 

 Just last year the government also announced the establishment of an "expert panel" to review Child Youth and Family services (New Zealand’s central government run child protection services). The so-called “expert panel” included not a single social work voice. The “expert panel” has now reported but the practical implications of their proposals are, as yet, unclear. They are, however, likely to have profound implications for the structure of child protection services, the registration of social workers (not yet mandatory), the surveillance of families at risk, the role of the NGO and for-profit sectors, and the future of social work education.  

Another very notable development, and one worth keeping your eye on from the UK, has been the government’s proposals to introduce a predictive risk modelling tool using data held on service users by all government agencies to predict the likelihood that families will maltreat their children. This is a deeply troubling development, reminiscent of the idea of predicting “future crime” explored in the movie “Minority report”. Except, this time it’s for real. Several social work academics from New Zealand and Australia have developed critiques of the tool that are well work reading (see references in the Re-Imagining Social Work blog cited below).

On a more positive note, partly in response to these recent assaults on social work, there have been several progressive developments.

The Aotearoa New Zealand Association of Social Workers (ANZASW) employed a Campaign Coordinator (one Luis Arevelo) who made active use of social media, and street campaigning work, to raise awareness about social issues, especially the connection between the anti-TPPA movement and social work. 
 
The Public Services Association (the main union for many social workers) has been very active through their own Social Workers Action Network actively campaigning, consciousness raising and organising local networks of social workers to monitor and resist regressive changes: https://www.psa.org.nz/at-work/networks/social-workers-action-network/
 
Several NZ academics combined to form the Re-imagining Social Work (RSW) Collective: a blogging collective formed to challenge the review of Child Youth and Family and to advance a progressive vision for social work practice. The blog has (in 2016 alone) had over 20,000 views from over 10,000 visitors: http://www.reimaginingsocialwork.nz/
 
Finally, the comrades working together in the RSW collective connected with some other academic colleagues to form an editorial collective for the ANZASW journal Aotearoa New Zealand Social Work. We have founded an international editorial advisory board (including comrades from SWAN) and have transformed the journal into a free, open access journal for all social workers worldwide. We welcome our UK colleagues as readers and contributors, just register online to stay up to date: https://anzswjournal.nz/anzsw
 
Colleagues and comrades, may your conference be a stimulating and inspiring one.
 
A luta continua.
 
Yours in solidarity,
 
Neil Ballantyne
 
Senior Lecturer (Open Polytechnic of New Zealand) and 
member of the Re-imagining Social Work Collective.
  • Tuam babies: How the English ‘sent back’ unmarried mothers to Ireland

Policy Press author, academic and SWAN Ireland member Paul Michael Garrett discusses the issues surrounding unmarried mothers in his book "Social work and Irish people in Britain". This blog post looks at this topic and touches on the recent story covering the headlines in Ireland, the Tuam babies.

Read More